Skip to main content

Why Members Sign Up Without a Plan

Memberstack Team
Memberstack Team
  • Updated

When a visitor registers with Memberstack, their member account can be created without an associated plan. This can happen intentionally, or it can indicate that the signup flow is not assigning a plan as expected.

Here are some common reasons a member may appear without a plan.

Missing Plan Attributes

If a signup form only includes:

data-ms-form="signup"

Memberstack creates the member account without assigning a plan.

To assign a free plan during signup, add the appropriate plan attribute:

data-ms-plan:add="pln_..."

For a paid plan, use the appropriate price attribute:

data-ms-price:add="prc_..."

If you are using Webflow, inspect the published page to make sure attributes such as data-ms-plan:add have not been altered or stripped.

Using :update Instead of :add

The :add and :update modifiers are used for different plan actions.

Use data-ms-plan:add or data-ms-price:add when the signup flow should add a free or paid plan to the member.

The data-ms-price:update custom attribute is intended to let members switch from an existing subscription to a different paid plan. For e.g. to upgrade from monthly to yearly paid plan. If a new member should receive a plan during signup or if you want to allow a member to have multiple paid plans, use :add instead.

Abandoned Paid Checkout

For paid plans, a member account can be created before the member completes Stripe Checkout.

If the member leaves checkout without completing the payment, the account can remain in Memberstack without an active plan.

This is expected behavior and does not necessarily indicate a problem with the signup form.

Plan or Price Attribute on the Wrong Element

Make sure the plan or price attribute is placed on the form or button responsible for the signup or purchase action, rather than on an unrelated wrapper or container.

If Memberstack cannot detect the plan or price attribute during the signup action, the member may be created without the intended plan.

Showing Content to Members Without a Plan

If your site allows members to create an account before choosing a plan, you can use:

data-ms-content="no-plans"

to display content specifically to members who do not have a plan.

For example, you could use this to display a message or upgrade prompt directing planless members to choose a plan.

Manually Assigning a Plan

If a member was created without a plan and you want to assign one manually, open the member in the Memberstack dashboard and use the Plans & Permissions section to add the appropriate plan.

Related Articles

For information about configuring signup forms and assigning plans with data attributes, see the relevant Memberstack forms and plan management guides: Creating Forms with Data Attributes, Plan Logic Recipes, and Plan Signup Rules.

Was this article helpful?

Didn’t find your answer?

Get an instant answer from Rey, or reach a human. Either way, we’re happy to help.

Comments

No comments yet. Start the conversation below.

Please sign in to leave a comment.